top of page

Best Restaurants in Downtown Hartwell

Updated: Apr 12, 2022

If you’re looking for a place to eat after a day on the lake, the town of Hartwell has plenty of options. Take a look at some of the restaurants in Hartwell, Ga around the square.

Downtown Hartwell has numerous shops and hangouts so it’s a great place to visit when you’re off the lake. And as the downtown sector has continued to grow, so have the number of restaurants.

The Best Restaurants in Downtown Hartwell, GA

After a long day of lake-based activities, there is sometimes nothing better than sliding into a booth in an air-conditioned restaurant. These restaurants are some local favorites where you can get excellent food when your stomach starts to growl.

Grab an Authentic New York Style Pizza

handmade pizzas at NY Pizza in Hartwell GA

A slice of NY in GA! New York Pizza in Hartwell is dedicated to serving the best pizza and Italian dishes in the area at an affordable price. New York Pizza certainly has longevity to back up its brand—with over 35 years in the business, it’s safe to say you’re going to get fantastic food.

You can dine in, call in, or order online. New York Pizza is open seven days a week, so you can get fabulous pizza any day of the week.

Website: Facebook: Instagram: @newyorkpizzaga

Enjoy Fresh Natural Food within an Old-Fashioned General Store

COFFEE bar at Market 50 in Hartwell GA

If it’s charm you’re after, Market 50 is the place to be. This shop is a family-run gift shop and deli. They serve sandwiches and salads with fresh ingredients as well as coffee, cakes and pies.  You can enjoy your lunch leisurely while your children browse the old-fashioned shop.

Bulk spices, nuts, and dried fruits are the perfect items to grab if you want to make your own trail mix for hiking at the lake. Plus, the friendly atmosphere will give you a full serving of Southern Hospitality.

Grab a Seat at a Local Brewery

Southern Hart Brewery bar in Hartwell GA

Want to grab a cold one after a hot day at Lake Hartwell? You definitely do not want to miss Southern Hart Brewing.

This trendy space has locally brewed beer in a low-key environment. They also offer a menu filled with simple favorites like the Hart burger, BLT and shredded chicken tacos.

If you plan accordingly, you can catch the space when a local musician is performing—dinner and a show.

Enjoy a Taste of the Mediterranean

bar at downtown cafe in hartwell ga

Always have a tough time deciding between Greek and Italian for dinner? At Downtown Cafe, you’ll never have to make that call again.

This downtown Hartwell restaurant is one of the most popular spots in town, thanks to their incredible dishes such as gyros, Zorba platters, shrimp scampi and in-house baked lasagna to name a few.

It’s the place to be on Friday and Saturday night, so reservations are recommended. Reservations can easily be made online, and once you come in to dine, you’ll be mingling with customers who have been going to Downtown Cafe for over 20 years.

Indulge in a Steak Dinner

skylight bar at Chicago Steakhouse in Hartwell, GA

Undoubtedly, one of the nicest restaurants at Lake Hartwell is the Chicago Steak House in Hartwell, GA. Master butchers prepare expertly aged marbled beef so that each bite is tender and juicy.

Kick it up a notch and top your steak with caramelized onions, bourbon mushrooms or smother your steak with blue cheese. Of course, for the non-steak eaters, there are still plenty of options to enjoy such as seared ahi tuna or jumbo lump crab cakes.

This is a restaurant perfect for special occasions or when you feel like treating yourself a bit after a long day boating and fishing.

No more wondering where to eat in downtown Hartwell

Are you drooling yet? Which one of these incredible Hartwell, Ga restaurants are you going to try first?

The best places to eat on the square in hartwell, ga. steak dinner with asparagus and potatoes
411 views0 comments

Related Posts

See All


bottom of page